Recent

A Path Appears

by Nicholas D. Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn

In some ways this book is an encyclopedia of non-profit organizations around the world. The information was collected by a husband wife team, who have written other significant books.  I was greatly moved by their book Half the Sky, which speaks to the oppression of women. This book is a book about hope.  The “path” referenced in the title is a path of hope.  The authors have identified hundreds of organizations who are doing humanitarian work around the globe and given us information about those organizations and what we can do to join them. Those organizations offer hope to millions of people—they are providing a “path” which we may follow or join.  The authors say, “Our efforts at altruism have a mixed record of success at helping others, but they have an almost perfect record of helping ourselves.  They can also be a way of asserting our values, or responding to pain or horror by reaffirming a higher standard of humanity.”

—Bernie Turner is a retired pastor living in McMinnville, OR.

Muhammad: A Biography of the Prophet

by Karen Armstrong, reviewed by Ray Berthiaume

"In the West we have a long history of hostility towards Islam that seems as entrenched as our anti-Semitism,” but now “for the first time in Islamic history, Muslims have begun to cultivate a passionate hatred of the West. In part this is due to European and American behaviour in the Islamic world" (p.11). "It is as impossible to generalize about Islam as about Christianity; there is a whole range of ideas and ideals in both" (p.13). "We shall see that Muhammad's spiritual experience bears an arresting similarity to that of the prophets of Israel, St. Teresa of Avila and Dame Julian of Norwich" (p.15).           

Muhammad is in the tradition of the Old Testament heroes like Moses, David, Solomon, Elijah and Isaiah—flawed and passionate and complex. We see him sometimes laughing, playing with his children, trying to placate his wives, weeping over a friend's death.

He had almost no contact with Judaism or Christianity. His monotheism was a challenge to the tribal Arabs who had little reason to give up their gods.

In 610, on Mount Hira, Muhammad had a mystical experience in which he began speaking the Qu'ran. He was very afraid and resistant to the idea he was called to be a prophet. Only after interior struggles did he accept his mission from God. He began openly teaching that all men and women should strive to create a just society where the vulnerable were treated decently. And all blessings come from al'Llah whose House was the Ka'aba. So each must "surrender" ("islam”) to the will of this God.

Karen Armstrong details much of the struggles and political conflict Muhammad had to endure for his mission. He comes across as a passionate, convicted holy man, trusting in al'Lah to see him through it. This is a valuable book to help dissipate the pervasive ignorance of Christians and Jews regarding the largest religion in the world.

—Ray Berthiaume lives in Memphis, Tennessee.

Practicing Discernment With Youth: A Transformative Youth Ministry Approach

by David White

I have been reading White’s work in preparation to teach a religious education class for youth. White, the former director of research for the Youth Theological Initiative at Candler School of Theology, speaks directly about the ways modern youth ministry has failed to effectively engage young people in the costly journey of discipleship. In response to youth ministry programs that, like many high schools, are concerned with preparing children to be good participants in the marketplace rather than risk-takers in the name of what is just and beneficial for creation, White lays out ways to engage youth in deep, serious discernment that accounts for their inherent gifts and insights. This last point, that youth are not incomplete adults but congregants with valuable offerings specific to their particular phase in life, changes not only how we must see youth ministry but how we must see all ministries. As White says at the outset of this book, “Congregations, adults and youth who engage each other in discernment…find that in discerning together, they are in fact doing much of the work of youth ministry (and adult ministry).”

—Hillary Brownsmith is the pastoral apprentice at Circle of Mercy Congregation, Asheville, NC.

Covenant Economics: A Biblical View of Justice for All

Richard Horsley

The Jewish-Christian movements have not always exemplified high moral standards.  Horsley points out that the American founding ‘fathers’ ‘not only took the land away from the peoples already living on it, but they slaughtered those peoples’ (p x).   Exactly what the Jewish people did in Canaan!  Horsley then articulates the framework of covenant economics that stood over against the Egyptian empire, tracing that covenantal society through the monarchy (and its economic centralization) and the prophetic condemnation when the covenantal perspectives were forgotten or ignored.  He then summarizes the Roman imperial economy, and sketches the framework of covenantal renewal that Jesus sought to bring; he finishes with a good summary of covenantal renewal emphasis in Mark, Paul and Matthew.

The Jewish economy was based on covenantal law codes:  the land belonged to Yahweh, land allocated was inalienable, the poor were provided for (gleaning, sabbatical fallow years, generous lending principles—no interest, realistic collateral, periodic cancellation of debts.  The Roman system subverted this economic perspective, with their repeated wars, their demand for tribute and their use of client rulers with no economic limits (e.g. Herod).

Jesus sought to restore the covenantal community (Matthew 5 and Luke 6 are covenant renewal speeches).  “Jesus and his envoys were building a movement village by village, not just calling individual followers” (p 109).  And Mark particularly articulates the characteristics of covenant community: marriage and family, children as models (westerners have romantic notions of children; for the ANE, children were the human beings with lowest status; for Jesus to declare that ‘the kingdom of G-d belongs to children emphasizes that the kingdom of G-d is present for the poor villagers, as opposed to the wealthy and powerful’ (p 119).  And Jesus’ declaration of principles governing community relations (leadership, Mark 10:42-45), constitutes a covenantal charter for the community of the Markan Jesus movement (p 123).

A wonderful book!

—Vern Ratzlaff, pastor and professor of historical theology at Lutheran Theological Seminary in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada

 

God and Empire

by John Dominic Crossan

From Marcion on, the church has wrestled with the concept of G-d that emerges from the Jewish-Christian scriptures:  the vengeful/violent G-d and the peace-committed vulnerable G-d.  Crossan focuses the issue well:  the story of Noah and the story of Abraham represent the two models given as G-d’s solution to a rebellious creation.  In the Noachic solution, G-d destroys the empire; G-d’s solution is to kill everyone except the family of Noah (p 64).  But the Noachic solution doesn’t work and so a new divine solution appears in Genesis 12;  the covenant of love that will invite all to the new family of faith.  Noah exterminates, Abraham converts.’  The solution of extermination by force and violence, and the Abrahamic solution of conversion to justice and peace, are never reconciled anywhere in the biblical tradition.  They are together from one end of it to the other.  Do we take them both and worship a G-d of both violence and nonviolence, or must we choose between them and recognize that the Bible proposes the radicality of a nonviolent G-d struggling with the normalcy of a violent civilization?’ (p 88)

The difference is underscored even more in the biblical hospitality eschatology:  the Noachic solution ends in a cannibalistic feast (Rev 19:17-21), the Abrahamic solution ends with a reconciling and peaceable society of food and grace.  Crossan chooses not the violence but the non-violent G-d revealed by Jesus.

 A crucial contribution to hermeneutical faithfulness.

—Vern Ratzlaff, pastor and professor of historical theology at Lutheran Theological Seminary in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada

Jesus and Empire

by Richard Horsley

The concept of “empire” has emerged as a crucial key in interpreting biblical stuff, and Horsley is one of the most insightful writers in this area.  Jesus and Empire documents how practises and effects of Roman imperialism decisively shaped the conditions of life in Galilee and Jerusalem.  These included the global subjugation of people, the emperor cult for theology, the need for feeding large unproductive segments of the population (“bread and circuses”), military violence as a control mechanism (eg crucifixion as intimidation, slaughter and mass enslavement, display of Roman army standards), indirect rule through client kings and religious priests (the threefold level of oppressive taxation in the Jewish territories: tribute to Romans, taxes to Herod, offerings and levies to the temple state).

Against this, “Jesus launched a mission not only to heal the debilitating effects of Roman military violence and economic exploitation, but   revitalize and rebuild the people’s cultural spirit and communal vitality….  In his offering the kingdom of G-d to the poor, hungry and despairing people, Jesus instilled hope in a seemingly hopeless situation, through his renewal of covenantal community, calling the people to common cooperative action to arrest the disintegration of their communities” (pp 126,127).

Horsley ends his book with a comparison of the Christian Empire and the American Empire, and the latter resembles the Roman Empire.  “Paul was building an international anti-imperial movement of an alternative society based in local communities” (p 133).

A wonderful read about the pressures on the church by empires, then and now.

 —Vern Ratzlaff, pastor and professor of historical theology at Lutheran Theological Seminary in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada

Jesus and the Peasants

by Douglas Oakman

It is tempting to read the New Testament, especially the stories of Jesus, as  nice little reflections on spiritual concerns—how to get along with our neighbours, how to live respectable lives of non-threatening piety. Oakman presents the culture Jesus lived in, an agrarian, a marginalized life, of peasant economics and values. But Oakman’s approach is wider than simply casting Jesus as a peasant; Jesus’ ideology is quite worldly’ (p 3).  Ancient economics is deeply implicated in ancient politics, so Jesus’ peasant aims were both profoundly political and entirely social, which helps explain why first century scribes recorded sayings and memories of a crucified, illiterate peasant with such care and diligence.

Oakman focuses on debt as one of the keys to understanding Jesus’ concerns.  When debtors defaulted, sale of assets (land), imprisonment or slavery were the usual consequences.  Jesus’ teaching on forgiveness, the abolition of debt, was a subversive revolutionary agenda (p 39); Jesus’ vision of liberation coming with the reign of G-d attacked the principle elements of the Roman order in Galilee.  G-d’s rule was a power opposed to the social order established by Rome; Jesus spoke on behalf of a politics of liberation and compassion, not of the issues of debts and defaulting.

The two most gripping sections of Oakman’s writing are his discussion of the Lord’s Prayer (the concept of debt) and the story of the “Foolish Samaritan” that sees the story as more than simply a model for good behaviour; G-d’s reign is “revealed in the wilds of bandits and inns….  The Samaritan indebts himself and the injured Jerusamelite into the power of the innkeeper” (p 179), giving the innkeeper (a notoriously bad lot by peasant standards) a blank cheque.

Oakman helps us read the Jesus story with new cultural eyes.

—Vern Ratzlaff, pastor and professor of historical theology at Lutheran Theological Seminary in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada

 

Perv: the sexual deviant in all of us

by Jesse Bering

Bering is a well-educated sexologist who has written about a huge variety of sexual classifications. Most of these classifications were completely unknown to me. There are a huge number of “philes” that are not in common usage, but are used by people studying human sexuality. He does a good job of working the issue of normal with these classifications and then asking the question about how we are to judge people with these kinds of deviances.

—Bernie Turner is a retired pastor living in McMinnville, OR

 

 

Dean Smith: A remembrance

by Ken Sehested

        I once preached in the Chapel Hill, North Carolina, church were legendary basketball coach Dean Smith was a member. Smith, who died this week, was not expected to be there that morning, since his University of Carolina team had a road game, far away, the night before. Then he and his wife slip in the back about the time I get up to read Scripture. I doubled-down on the text and tried not to make eye contact during the sermon.

        In my youth I played every sport that used a ball, of whatever shape or size, from dirt yard marbles to Boys Club ping pong to Division 1 college football. I loved the college campus recruiting visits, during high school, receiving a bit of “expense” money, prowling the game time sideline with the prospective team and a pre-arranged dance date after the game. Though I always felt bad about the unlucky coed assigned to this high schooler who, to add insult to injury, didn’t dance or drink, for reasons of evangelical piety. Though I’m not an active participant in the muckraking exposure of how major college athletics programs find themselves awash in cash, I applaud that exposure.

        The capitalizing of college sports, in particular, is tragic. For example, the legendary Hall of Fame football coach Woody Hayes of Ohio State was among college football’s royalty from the ‘50s through the ‘70s, making a bit over $40,000 in later years.  The new legendary coach at Ohio State makes $4,000,000. The Great Recession mostly exempted major college sports.

        Other examples are easy to find. In 2012 Texas A&M quarterback Johnny Manziel won the coveted Heisman Trophy, college football’s highest honor, the first freshman so selected. Manziel is known for his distinctive victory dance after scoring touchdowns, rubbing his thumbs and forefingers together in the universal “show me the money” sign language. This past January, during the televised broadcast of a college football bowl game, an ESPN reporter gleefully described one standout player as having a “big heart and no conscience.”

        The comment has a gladiatorial quality—and nothing in common with the great psychologist Abraham Maslow’s view that “Almost all creativity involves purposeful play.”

        Given current brazen realities, it's particularly appropriate to remember Dean Smith, hall-of-fame basketball coach at the University of North Carolina, who died this week.

        Part of the news coverage of Coach Smith’s passing is this tribute from his pastor, Rev. Robert Seymour, retired pastor of Binkley Baptist Church in Chapel Hill.

        “[Smith] was willing to take controversial stands on a number of things as a member of our church, being against the death penalty, affirming gays and lesbians, protesting nuclear proliferation. He was one who has been willing to speak out on issues that many might hesitate to take a stand on." He was among the first coaches in the South to recruit a black player, and he caught hell over it.

        Coach Smith’s character is testified to by his 96% graduation rate among players, many of whom he kept up with after their departure, including Hall of Famer Michael Jordan. Both his former players and coaching colleagues testify to what Smith taught them, not just about the game but also about people and about life.

        Smith has been credited with a number of tactical innovations in the game that remain, none more common—in collegiate as well as in pro basketball—of a successful shooter pointing to the teammate who passed him the ball. He took talented individual players and taught them to play as a team rather than as individual stars.

        Where I grew up, basketball was a distant second to football’s popularity. But every time I hear the round ball’s echo off a hardwood court, it makes me remember that my Mom taught me the game, she having been a high school all-state player and, for a season, a semi-pro player in one of the industrial leagues that formed during the 1940s. “I was a bit chubby then, particularly for a basketball player, and frequently got unkind remarks from the opposing team’s bench,” she once told me. “But when I kept scampering by their defenders, they shut up.”

        I suspect the ability to play and the ability to pray come from common sources. To do either well, you have to be all in, purposefully, but always prepared for surprising turns. Both invite a certain abandonment, the pursuit significantly influenced neither by desire to win nor fear of loss, the playing and the praying being their own sufficient goals. All awareness of the self as separate from the activity is eclipsed, the sheer delight overshadowing whatever difficulties accompany. A joyful freedom displaces fretful obsession.

        In the immortal words of Kris Kristofferson, “Freedom’s just another word for nothing left to lose.” Which enables you, in the equally immortal words of Satchel Page, to “Work like you don’t need the money. Love like you’ve never been hurt. Dance like nobody’s watching.”

©Ken Sehested @ prayerandpolitiks.org

Pursuing God’s Presence

An annotated review of selected authors

by Nancy Sehested

My sermon this week is not on a particular biblical text but a review of other texts which have deeply influenced my personal formation as a follower of Jesus. My preparation involved lingering at my bookshelf, pulling out those books that were the most worn, the ones I return to again and again. It is not an exhaustive list, of course, but it offers a window into the writers who have become my companions for the inner journey. I spoke about them as God’s gardeners of my soul, people who have inspired me to live more fully and deeply. As you can see they are from a wide range of religions and from no particular religion at all. I have found them an encouragement to go more deeply into my own chosen path as a Christian. My hope is that this list will take you to your own reflection about the people who have deepened your soul.

Meditation by Eknath Easwaran (1910-1999)
In college and seminary I took courses on Eastern religions and Eastern mysticism. I was introduced to the Hindu teacher Eknath Easwaren. His 8-point program of meditation is a particularly helpful tool for someone like me who has difficulty quieting my mind. His method suggests meditating on sacred texts to begin your meditation. He thought memorizing St. Francis Prayer or the 23rd Psalm was ideal for beginners. His methods teach me still. He has many other books. Among them is an excellent biography of Gandhi, titled Gandhi the Man (1972).

Creative Prayer by Brigid E. Herman (1875-1923)
Brigid Herman was born in Prague and died in London at the age of 48. I was introduced to her tiny book by Sister Ellen, my spiritual director, who was a Roman Catholic sister. I’d never heard of a spiritual director until I met her. She came to me at a time in my early ministry when I was overwhelmed. I knew that I needed far more inner resources to survive the day to day work of pastoring. Sister Ellen was a wise and gentle guide. She walked me through lectio divina on the life of Christ. We met weekly for one year. She encouraged me to maintain a rigorous practice of one hour of centering prayer, lectio divina, and journaling 5 days a week. She introduced me to the rich, centuries-old history of Christian meditation and contemplative prayer. She gave me the book by Herman. It was written more than a century ago. Herman’s language is archaic, but then my language is often considered that way too. Yet her work is a basic primer on prayer, silence and contemplation. Sister Ellen taught me for one complete year. The day after we completed our one year commitment to meditative practices, she was killed in a car accident. I miss her still.

The Essential Rumi translated by Coleman Barks
Jelaluddin Balkhi, known as “Rumi, was born in 1207 in Afghanistan, which was then part of the Persian empire. His family emigrated to Turkey. Rumi was a Sufi mystic who wrote numerous poems. One snippet of his poetry:
      The morning wind spreads its fresh smell,
      We must get up and take that in, that wind that lets us live.
      Breathe before its gone
.

The Gift: Poems by Hafiz the Great Sufi Master translated by Daniel Ladinsky
Hafiz was a Sufi mystic who was born about 100 years after Rumi. He is considered the most beloved poet of Persia. He was born in Shiraz and lived from c.1320-1389.
      Some lines from his poetry:
      I am a hole in a flute that Christ’s breath moves through—Listen to this Music. Every Child has known God,
      not the God of names, not the God of don’ts, not the God who ever does anything weird, but the God who
      only knows four words and keeps repeating them, saying, “Come dance with Me.”

Rilke’s Book of Hours: Love Poems to God translated by Anita Barrows & Joanna Macy
Rainer Maria Rilke was born in Prague in 1875. He wrote this book of love poems to God in about 1900. One part of one of the poem prayers:
      I love you, gentlest of Ways, who ripened us as we wrestled with you. You the great homesickness
       we could never shake off, you the forest that always surrounded us….

Other poets that I love include works by Denise Levertov, Mary Oliver, Annie Dillard, and Naomi Shihad Nye.

The Long Loneliness by Dorothy Day
By Little and By Little: The Selected Writings of Dorothy Day edited by Robert Ellsberg

Dorothy Day (1897-1980) was a journalist and social activist. She was a founder of the Catholic Worker Movement that offered direct aid to people who were poor along with non-violent advocacy actions on their behalf. She was arrested numerous times for her civil disobedience. She lived in a small room in one of the Catholic Worker houses in New York City alongside the people who she served.  She did not think that works of mercy could be separated from works of peace. She wrote:
      Neither revolutions nor faith is won without keen suffering.

Messengers of God by Elie Wiesel
Eliezer "Elie" Wiesel is a Romanian-born Jewish-American professor and political activist. He is the author of 57 books, including perhaps his best known book Night, a work based on his experiences as a prisoner in the concentration camps. He was born in 1928. He won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1986. I took a class with him when I was in seminary. I was captivated with his depth, honesty, and humanity. As a preacher I have benefited greatly from his books, especially his books that focus on biblical portraits. In class he said again and again that the worst stance in times of terror and violence is indifference.
      The opposite of love is not hate, it's indifference. The opposite of art is not ugliness, it's indifference.
      The opposite of faith is not heresy, it's indifference. And the opposite of life is not death, it's
      indifference.

The Writings of Thich Nhat Hanh
Thich Nhat Hanh was born in 1926 in Vietnam. He is a Zen Buddhist monk, writer, teacher, poet, and social activist. He lives in Plum Village in France. I have gleaned from his wisdom for many, many years. I left most of my books by him at the prison for the Buddhist prisoners to read. One piece of his voluminous writings:
      We humans have lost the capacity of resting. We worry too much. We don’t allow our bodies to heal.
       We don’t allow our minds to heal. Our worries, stress, and fear make the situation worse.
      Meditation can help release the tension, help us embrace our worries, our fear, our anger; and that
      is very healing.

I Asked for Wonder by Abraham Joshua Heschel
Abraham Joshua Heschel was born in 1907 in Poland. He was a descendant of a long line of Hasidic rabbis. He was a theologian, poet, mystic, writer, teacher, social activist and historian. He arrived in America in 1939. He marched for civil rights with Martin Luther King, Jr. He gave himself to the social issues of his time, resisting racism, economic injustice and the Vietnam war. He taught for many years at Jewish Theological Seminary in New York City. The day before his death he insisted on going to the federal prison in Connecticut to wait for his friend, a Catholic priest, to be released after doing time for civil disobedience. He stood in the freezing snow. He died the next day on a Sabbath evening. A few years before his death in 1972 he prayed:
      I did not ask for success. I asked for wonder. And You gave it to me.

Three books by Howard Thurman:
Deep is the Hunger, Jesus and the Disinherited, and With Head and Heart

Howard Thurman was born in Daytona Beach in 1899 and died in San Francisco in 1981.  I heard him speak at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine in NYC in 1980. Dr. Thurman was a pastor, theologian, philosopher, professor, dean, writer, and mystic. It is said that during the times when Martin Luther King Jr. was jailed for his civil disobedience, he took with him two books. One was the bible and the other was Thurman’s book Jesus and the Disinherited. I kept that book within arm’s reach of my desk during my 13 years as a prison chaplain. It provided one of the best interpretations of the temptations of those who are in powerless situations. Thurman wrote about the ways in which oppressed people can be tempted to live out of fear, deception and hate. He offered the radical way of Jesus, naming the power of love to transform and heal. Some of his words on that topic:
      Jesus’ message focused on the urgency of a radical change in the inner attitude of the people. He
      recognized fully that out of the heart are the issues of life and that no external force, however great
      and overwhelming, can at long last destroy a people if it does not first win the victory of the spirit
      against them.

The Silent Cry: Mysticism and Resistance by Dorothee Soelle (1929-2003)
Dr. Soelle was a peace and environmental activist. She was a feminist theologian who was one of my seminary professors. Among her many books is this one that integrates her thoughts on resistance and mysticism. She was an interdisciplinary thinker with formal studies and degrees from her German homeland in philosophy, ancient languages, literature and theology.  She couldn’t sing worth a toot, but that never stopped her from belting out hymns with great gusto and joy. From this book:
      I am neither professionally anchored nor personally at home in the two institutions of religion, the
      church and academic theology. It is the mystical element that will not let go of me… I can simply say
      that what I want to live, understand, and make known is the love for God. And that seems to be in
      little demand in those two institutions.

An Interrupted Life: The Diaries of Etty Hillesum 1941-1943                                
Etty Hillesum died at Auschwitz at the age of 29. She was a Dutch Jew who began her diaries about the same time as a younger Dutch girl, Anne Frank, began her diaries. Anne Frank was hidden in a house only a few miles from Etty’s room in Amsterdam. Some of my friends who began reading this book never got past the first half of it. Etty was self-absorbed with many sexual escapades. To me that part of the story makes her very human. And if you keep reading you discover a young woman who went through a transformation. As her outer world became increasingly small, Etty’s inner world became increasingly large.
      The sky within is as wide as the one stretching out above my head.
She flung open every door of her heart, unafraid to explore all corners of her being. She searched the darkened rooms, with only her longings as light, and did not stop until she found where love was hiding. She refused to allow her enemies to control her spirit. She chose love of her enemies rather than hatred. Her writings came to me at a critical time in my journey when enemies surrounded me in the public struggle for women’s pastoral leadership in the church. Becoming just like my hateful enemies was easy to pull off. My heart went to war many times. But Etty urged me to choose a path of true freedom, a path of peace, a path of mercy. My book of her diaries is in shreds. Etty remains one of my most beloved teachers. Her heart beat with love in the ruins of hate. In one of her letters to God:
      Dear God, these are anxious times. Tonight I lay in the dark with burning eyes as scene after scene
      of human suffering passed before me….I shall try to help You, God, to stop my strength ebbing
      away, though I cannot vouch for it in advance. But one thing is becoming increasingly clear to me:
      that You cannot help us, that we must help You to help ourselves. And that is all we can manage
      these days and also all that really matters: that we safeguard that little piece of You, God, in
      ourselves. And perhaps in others as well…I shall bring You all the flowers I shall meet on my way…I
      shall try to make You at home always. Even if I should be locked up in a narrow cell and a cloud
      should drift past my small barred window, than I shall bring you that cloud, oh God, while there is
      still the strength in me to do so.

prayerandpolitiks.org. Nancy Sehested is co-pastor of Circle of Mercy Congregation in Asheville, NC. This sermon was preached in June 2014 at High Country United Church of Christ in Boone, NC.